728x90
my iParenting
From Our Sponsors
e-newsletters
Sign up to receive our free weekly e-newsletters

new terms of use
new privacy policy
award-winning products
The iParenting Media Awards program helps parents find the best products for their families.

Pregnancy Today's Advisory Panel Answers:
Can tell the baby's sex by its heartbeat or by the way you are carrying it?

by Lisa Miller
Certified Nurse-Midwife
Swedish Covenant Hospital, Chicago
Lisa Miller

Question

Is there any truth to the old wives tale that you can tell the baby's sex by its heartbeat or by the way you are carrying it?

Answer

While old wives tales can be amusing, those of us in the medical profession don't use the baby's heart rate as a determiner of sex. A study mentioned in the Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine, "found there was no difference in male and female fetal heart at anytime during pregnancy." (JUM, 7:237-238, 1988) Results of another study, published in Britain's Clinical Science (92, 345–349, 1997) echoed these findings.

There is no truth to the myth that you can tell the sex of the baby by the way you are carrying it, meaning low or high. And if people tell you differently, remember, any method (even a coin toss) is going to be correct about half the time! Ultrasound is much more dependable, and amniocentesis is the most reliable of all.

This Week's Expert Q & A

Kathy Loebel, certified nurse-midwife, answers: “How can I avoid an episiotomy or tearing?"

Read more in the Health Q&A Library
and in the Lifestyle answers forum
Ask your own question
or come meet our Health Expert Panelists!


Have a question for one of our experts?
Ask it at the Q & A desk!